1 / 7Big Potato Herd Mentality Board Game HMDTC01UKv3
HMDTC01UKv3: Big Potato Herd Mentality is a family and party board game in which players write answers and score by matching the majority. Its listing describes play for 4 to 20 people, with no trivia knowledge needed, making it suited to larger gatherings where shared answers and conversation are the point.
At a glance
- Everyone answers the same question, matching the majority earns cow tokens, while the odd answer earns the Pink Cow.
- The listing says 4 to 20 players can all play at once.
- Promoted as a no-trivia game: winning depends on anticipating popular answers rather than knowing facts.
- The manufacturer describes the rules as quick to learn, with no lengthy setup.
Often bought together
Sounds Fishy Card Game: Funny Bluffing Trivia Game for Families, Ages 10+ | Bluffing Beats Brains, Family Card Game, Party Trivia Game for Kids and Adults, Know It or Make It Up, Christmas Quiz Game
£13.99
The Chameleon Board Game: Catch The Traitors Party Game for Adults & Teens | Spot the Imposter Card Game, Traitors Board Game for Adults and Teens, Award-Winning Party Game, Christmas Games for Families
£14.99
Pros and cons
Pros
- A stated 4–20 player range suits groups larger than many tabletop games accommodate.
- The answer-matching format gives children and adults a shared basis for play without requiring general-knowledge expertise.
- The supplied questions, answer pads and tokens support repeated rounds of group discussion.
Cons
- Play depends on a group enjoying open-ended answers and trying to predict what others will say, it is not a trivia or strategy challenge focused on factual mastery.
Technical specifications
12 specifications| Brand | Big Potato |
|---|---|
| Model | HMDTC01UKv3 |
| Edition | Family Edition |
| Genre | Family, Strategy |
| Game mechanics | social deduction |
| Players | 20 |
| Recommended age | 10 years and up |
| Language | English |
| Batteries required | No |
| Operation mode | Manual |
| Material listed | Cardboard |
|---|---|
| Dimensions listed | 14 x 5 x 0.1 centimetres |
What’s in the box
Included- 1 Cow Paddock
- 1 Squishy Cow
- 2 Answer Pads
- 1 Rules Sheet
- 220 questions
- 62 Cow Tokens
Who is it for?
A good fit for
- Families and mixed-age groups looking for a discussion-led game, the listing recommends ages 10 and up.
- Parties and gatherings that need a game stated to accommodate up to 20 players.
Less suited to
- Buyers seeking a quiet, solo or two-player game, or a fact-based quiz.
Customer reviews on Amazon
- 5 stars
78% 78% - 4 stars
16% 16% - 3 stars
4% 4% - 2 stars
1% 1% - 1 star
1% 1%
Customer feedback describes the game as fun, quick to learn and fast-paced, with amusing debates and appeal across ages, those points fit its simple majority-matching format and stated capacity of up to 20 players. Value opinions are mixed: some consider it worth the money, while others question the price relative to the number of questions. The aggregate rating is 4.7 out of 5 from 6,082 ratings, but ratings alone do not explain individual experiences.
Positive themes
- Customers describe the game as fun, easy to learn, family-friendly and quick-paced, and report that it can work for groups of up to 20.
Negative themes
- Some customers consider it overpriced for the number of questions included.
Mixed feedback
- Value and question quality receive mixed feedback, some customers consider it worth the money, while others do not.
Frequently asked questions
How many people can play Herd Mentality?
The feature listing gives a range of 4 to 20 players, with everyone playing at once.
How does the game work?
Players answer a question, then score by matching the majority. The listing says an answer outside the herd earns the Pink Cow.
Does it require trivia knowledge?
The listing presents it as a game of predicting popular answers, not answering general-knowledge questions.
What age is it recommended for?
The manufacturer’s recommended age is 10 years and up.
Alternative options
Family Judgement - The Hilarious Family Voting Board Game! Great Family Board Games for Kids & Adults…
£21.99
Hitster Guilty Pleasures - The Ultimate Music Party Board Game for Adults | 300+ Iconic Hits - Friends & Family Timeline Trivia Game, Parties & Games Nights - Christmas Gift - 2-10 Players Age 16+ (UK)
£21.99
You Can’t Say Umm Party Game: Fast Board Game for Adults, Kids and Families | Quick-fire word challenge, 4-10 players, ages 8+, for teens, hen parties and games nights, Christmas gift, stocking fillers
£14.99
GorillaGames Say It First: Fast-Paced Word Game for Families & Friends | Hilarious Family Party Game of Speed & Shouts for 2-6 players | 200 Trivia & Party Questions
£24.95
More or Less Card Game - Board Games for Adults & Teens | Age 12+ | How Good is Your Judgement? First Edition. For 2 or more players. Ideal for travel, holidays, and play anywhere fun
£11.35
Grab The Mic - Award Winning Karaoke Party Game for Bad Singers w Foam Mic | 120 Word Cards (250 Words), 2-12 Players for ages 8+. Perfect For Family Game Night, Birthdays & Sing-Off Parties.
£19.99
Exploding Kittens Original Edition, 2-5 Players, Ages 7+ Card Game | Draw cards, betray your friends, and try not to explode! Great for family game nights, parties, travel, quick 15-minute play.
£19.99
Exploding Kittens Happy Salmon, 3-8 Players, Ages 6+ Group Card Game | Frantically shout your actions, find a matching player, complete the action, and discard your card. Fast 90-second travel fun
£12.99
Amazon Basics Junior BPA-Free 4-to-Score Giant Premium Plastic Games Set, 4 in A Row for Kids and Adults with Carrying Bag, Great For Gifting, Variety of Colors, Blue, Yellow, Red, Green, Large
£123.97
Drumond Park Articulate Family Board Game, The Fast Talking Description Games For Adults And Kids Suitable From 12+ Years For 4-20+ Players
£18.00
